May 30, 2023
Dear Leland and Everett,
“I know what I need to do…so why haven’t you done it already?!”
I’ve been struggling to articulate something I notice regularly, whether in politics, family dynamics, or other relationships. We notice some problem or behavior, and it really bothers us. Usually the behavior repeats, either because the same person acts in the same manner, or because we experience some version of the same behavior at home, at work, and in the news. For an example, think about a mom who gets upset every time a child does something…and the child does that thing (or some variation of it) over and over. Or consider a political party who gets upset every time the other party does something…and the other party does the thing over and over again. Or even the person who gets roiled over what they see in the news…only to see variations of the same outrage played out over and over.
Why do we do this? Why do we get irrationally angry over someone else’s behavior? (Why do I say it’s irrational? Because we stew on these perceived injustices for hours, and sometimes even days, often despite a complete lack of ability to control or even influence the parties involved.) I’ve come to believe that any time we get particularly upset, it has more to do with ourselves than with the offending party. So I’m learning to turn my attention inward when I get upset, to understand what’s really going on with me. What I notice most commonly is that when someone (or some behavior) offends me repeatedly, it’s because I’m avoiding something. And of course, I don’t want to notice that I’m avoiding something, so my psyche works very hard to help me not notice the thing I’m avoiding. And apparently one of our psyche’s best tricks is to help us notice the same (or what we perceive to be the same) avoidant behavior in others. Constantly noticing a failing in others helps us convince ourselves that we don’t have the same failing, or at least not to the same degree. So we don’t need to solve our problem, they just need to solve their problem.
But we notice and get frustrated precisely because some part of our soul knows what we need to do, and keeps reminding us. So when we notice a particularly frustrating behavior over and over, it’s because our soul is really pushing us to learn something about ourselves, and convince us to take action. And so we get stuck in a dance, where our soul keeps bringing something to our attention, and we work harder and harder at avoiding the thing by getting increasingly exasperated by those around us. It’s a strange dichotomy, but there it is.
“I know what I need to do…so why haven’t you done it already?!”
The soul knows. But the ego resists.
We just came home from a trip over the long weekend. We rented a house with another family, a family we see and travel with frequently. The parents are some of our closest friends, and we are lucky to have kids of similar ages. Every time we visit or vacation together, everyone has lots of fun.
But for whatever reason, I have a tendency to get irrationally frustrated with their eldest son. I say this not with righteousness, or even pride. I say this to help illustrate how this child has been one of the most important teachers in my life.
Robert (not his real name) is an energetic, outgoing, kind, caring, sweet young boy. He’s also reasonably strong willed. Like all children (and adults for that matter) he’s less agreeable when he’s tired or hungry. He can get so excited to be around others that he can barely contain himself. And when he’s not getting the attention he wants, he can get frustrated and misbehave.
I originally noticed my frustration with Robert couple years ago, when he was 3. My perception at the time was that Robert’s parents had limited ability to reign in his bad behavior. To be very clear, all kids (especially 3-year olds) behave badly sometimes. My perception was that Robert’s parents struggled to set clear boundaries, such that Robert knew where his limits were. Because Robert didn’t have clear boundaries (or so I thought), his parents spent a lot of energy attempting to correct his behavior. Unfortunately for them, Robert often ignored them, forcing them to either spend more energy attempting to correct, or giving up in frustration.
Eventually Robert would break one of our house rules (like not picking up after himself), and I would intervene, asking Robert to abide by our rules when visiting our house. Robert tried to ignore me like his parents, but I would intervene, usually picking him up, looking him in the eyes, and explaining that I needed his cooperation following our house rules. Invariably Robert complied, and I think our relationship is stronger precisely because I set firm boundaries with him.
But I found myself thinking about Robert days after we saw him. I would imagine scenarios playing (“and when he says this, I will say that; and when he does this, I will do that”), when it suddenly hit me how absurd this all was. Robert was 3, and I was expending a ridiculous amount of energy trying to control a 3-year old that wasn’t even mine! Clearly a 3-year old isn’t acting in malice, and any perception otherwise was me projecting. That, finally, was when I realized that my frustrations with Robert had little to do with Robert, and everything to do with me.
So I meditated with the question: why does this bother me so much? My first order answer was that I was frustrated with Robert’s dad for not setting firmer boundaries with Robert. But I realized this was a copout: I was just shifting blame from Robert to his father. My second order answer was that I didn’t think Robert’s dad was providing enough of a masculine presence in his household. And that’s when it hit me: my real frustration was that I didn’t think I was providing enough of a masculine presence in my household. As soon as I identified the true source of my frustration, I stopped worrying about Robert at all, and focused on the work I needed to do within me.
Since then I’ve noticed various ways in which Robert’s dad sets clear boundaries with him. Did Robert’s dad change, or did my perception change? I honestly don’t know the answer to that, but I wouldn’t be surprised if it was more about my perception than any behavioral change in Robert’s family.
A year later, as Robert and Everett got old enough to become playmates, I started to notice that Robert didn’t always “play fair”. Sometimes he would take something from Everett. Sometimes he would purposely knock over something Everett was building. Sometimes he would even push or scratch Everett. Everett, being the younger brother, was used to crying to adults to get his way. But this wasn’t really working for Everett in this situation: the adults weren’t paying close enough attention to ensure fair outcomes, and weren’t interested in spending all our time together refereeing between you two.
And yet, I found myself deeply frustrated on Everett’s behalf. So I asked myself why. The first order answer was that I didn’t want Robert to bully Everett. The second order answer was that I didn’t want Everett to let Robert bully him. The real answer was that I was tired of feeling bullied myself (at work, but also at home).
[Everett: This particular story has an interesting ending: on another weekend trip, I pulled Everett aside and said “Everett, you are bigger and stronger than Robert. You don’t have to let him take things from you. You can stand up for yourself.” I didn’t go into any more specifics, but sensed you understood. A few minutes later, Robert knocked down something you were building. You looked him square in the eyes and shouted “STOP!”. This got the moms’ attention, and your mom said “He didn’t mean it Everett”; after things calmed down I pulled her aside. Before I said anything, she said “I know, I did that”. I said to her gently but firmly, “when our son is being bullied, you do not stand up for the bully”. I explained that Robert had, in fact, knocked the structure down on purpose, and that you were within your rights to stand up for yourself. I believe she then followed up and apologized, but she definitely did more to look out for your needs since. Later, Robert tried to take away a stuffy you found at the house and really liked. You objected, and Robert screamed. The moms intervened and decided you should take turns. To your credit, you moved on and did something else. After a few minutes, Robert stood up and waived the stuffy in front of you. It worked: you stood up to try to get the stuffy back from him, sensing that it was rightfully your turn. Robert ran away in glee, until you caught up to him, at which point he screamed again. You let go lest the moms get involved again, and he ran away in glee again. I walked to see what would happen: I found you both on top of a bunk bed. You had chased Robert up onto the top bunk, and you had him trapped. You weren’t actively coming after the stuffy, but it was clear to both of you that you weren’t letting him off the bed with the stuffy. At this point Robert’s dad arrived, surveyed the situation for a few seconds, and asked “Robert, do you want to take a nap?” Robert said yes, handed you the stuffy, and crawled down to go take a 2-hour nap. He just needed some help, and didn’t know how to ask for it. I was so proud of how you handled that situation, and that weekend in general.]
I am thrilled to report that I didn’t experience any particular frustration with Robert on our most recent trip. In fact, I found myself feeling sad for Robert. I perceived that most of his misbehavior seems to be an effort to get the attention of his parents, or his friends (in this case, you guys). One morning I watched him start grabbing food while announcing “I’m hungry”. Your mom calmly and warmly offered to help him. She clarified what he wanted and heated it up for him. Robert calmly sat and ate, and I think even visited with your mom a bit. What particularly struck me: I’ve seen almost identical interactions be much more contentious between Robert and the adults in his life. I was reminded this weekend that Robert is an energetic, playful, kind, sweet boy who sometimes cannot contain his excitement around others, but really just wants to be loved.
Of course, I’m still not really talking about Robert. I’m really talking about me. I don’t know how he does it, but Robert teaches me more about myself than almost anyone else I know. He’s helped me become more aware of myself and my flaws, he’s helped me identify what I need to do to improve myself and create the person and the life that I want. I’m grateful that I have him in my life, and I really look forward to seeing him and his parents again soon.
I love you,
Eric